Welcome to Old Time Pizza
Old Time Pizza, nestled in New Paris, IN, offers a charming dining experience with a delightful range of pizzas and fresh menu options. Customers rave about the generous toppings on their pies, particularly the Supreme pizza, infused with cheese, veggies, and assorted meats. The atmosphere radiates a warm, hometown feel, enhanced by friendly service from the staff. Guests are pleased with quick service and cleanliness, making it a perfect spot for family outings or casual dinners. With affordable prices, this quaint pizza joint excels in comfort food, ensuring that each meal leaves patrons eager to return for more.
-
19152 Co Rd 46, New Paris, IN 46553, United States Hotline: +1 574-831-4160
Welcome to Old Time Pizza, a charming dining destination tucked away in New Paris, Indiana. This local gem, located at 19152 Co Rd 46, New Paris, IN 46553, is quickly gaining a reputation for its delightful pizzas and warm, friendly atmosphere. With a focus on quality ingredients and a welcoming environment, Old Time Pizza stands out in the bustling category of family eateries.
Customers rave about the generous portions, with plenty of cheese and a medley of fresh toppings that elevate each pizza to new heights. One delighted patron, Heather Shoopman, emphasizes the delicious offerings and amicable staff, stating, “I can’t wait to try out more of their menu.” This sentiment is echoed by Carla Humble, who enjoyed a fantastic meal featuring a fresh salad, steaming breadsticks, and a supreme pizza rich with cheese and vegetables. The friendly service and cozy vibe create an experience that feels like home!
Old Time Pizza prides itself on not just the delectable pizzas but also their other menu items. From stuffed breadsticks drizzled with garlic butter to succulent broasted chicken, every choice serves to please the palate. Customer Stephanie Stewart noted the warm hospitality of the staff and how the flavors remained consistently delightful, even after years. This kind of reliability is hard to come by and speaks volumes about the restaurant’s dedication to excellence.
For families, dining here is effortless, as showcased by Megan Stanger's experience with her group celebration. She appreciated the quick service and cleanliness of the venue, underscoring the accommodating nature of the restaurant. Whether ordering takeout or enjoying a meal in-house, guests like Randall Perry and Becky Moser emphasize the value offered, with meals under $20, making it easy to satisfy every craving without breaking the bank.
With rave reviews from patrons and a commitment to fresh food, Old Time Pizza is becoming a must-try for both locals and visitors alike. Next time you're in the area, don’t miss out on this quaint pizza joint that promises not just a meal but a delightful dining experience filled with warmth and friendliness. Grab your loved ones and head over, because at Old Time Pizza, every bite feels like a home-cooked meal shared amongst friends.
They have really good pizzas! And the staff are friendly. I can’t wait to try out more of their menu. Definitely recommend going here.
Wonderful hometown feel. Wonderful service. Wonderful fresh food. We had tossed salad-- very fresh and tasty; bread sticks-- hot and fresh u have a choice of dripping sauce-- cheese, garlic butter and Marinera. Supreme pizza-- lots of cheese, veggies and meats it was great. We will order or come here again.
Very quaint pizza joint but worth the visit. Super friendly owner/staff. Food was hot, fresh, and delicious. I hadn't been here for years in between and I guess they have new owners but the flavor is still the same as years ago.
Pleasantly surprised by this pizza. Not what I recall from years ago, but a good improvement. I really like the meat pizza and my kids loved the cheese.
We stopped in here on a Sunday evening with a group. We had my some birthday here and instead of carrying in food we brought the boys out. Old time pizza was very accommodating and helpful. Food came out really fast. Location is nice and clean.
The woman who took my order over the phone was so nice! Wonderful pizza and lovely restaurant. Would recommend, we'll be back.
Nice small town restaurant with a good variety of food options. They are generous with their mozzarella on pizzas, the breaded portobello mushrooms are great!
Excellent experience for where to dine in, or take out ! Pizza is very good & large you don't need to a add more cheese ! Broasted fried chicken & or Pork Chops ! Every meal is 20.00 or less, dine in or carry out, you'll be impressed !!!