Old Time Pizza Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Old Time Pizza, a quaint pizza joint nestled in the heart of New Paris, Indiana. This charming restaurant offers a menu bursting with delicious options that cater to every palate. Guests rave about the pizza, particularly the Supreme, loaded with generous amounts of mozzarella, fresh veggies, and savory meats.

The menu doesn’t stop at pizza; indulge in their tantalizing breadsticks served hot with a choice of dipping sauces, including cheese, garlic butter, and marinara. Diners appreciate the fresh tossed salads, a perfect complement to any main dish.

Whether dining in or taking out, Old Time Pizza combines friendly service with delicious food, ensuring an enjoyable experience for all. With most meals priced at $20 or less, it’s an excellent choice for families and gatherings. Visit Old Time Pizza, where nostalgic flavors meet modern hospitality!